Fun to drive commuter cars for college?

I'm a 19 year old guy. I've been driving an 01 corrolla for the last 3 years and would like a change.

I do not want to spend a lot of money on a car, but I want something that looks nice inside and will be something I look forward to driving in the morning.

I've looked at the following:

Scion FR-S (the car I want most. Great looking, a little kick, great mpg but the insurance is high and 18,000 is a lot for a car I'm just gonna out miles on)

Honda Civic Si: I love the interior, looks very sporty INSIDE. I hate how civics look on the outside though. Ugh. Great in mpg and good on insurance.

Mazda 3: looks like a chick car, but look reliable and are good on gas and mpg. But pretty boring otherwise. Feel like it's something my girlfriend would drive

350z: questionable reliability but no doubt I would have fun in it. Eh mpg and high insurance.

Ford Mustang: questionable reliability, boring build but quick and decent on gas and to insure

Lexus is250: can only get one with higher miles, smooth ride, great interior, eh mpg and good insurance

Then I've thought about going the cheaper route like:

S10 pickup
Nissan 300zx
Older Mustang Cobra
Older Civic Si
Mazda Rx-8

I ride dirt bikes, so a pick up would come in handy if I want to go to the track and take my bike. But its a tough call.

Fun to drive (not necessarily fast just fun) reliable, and something that isn't going to cost more than my tuition when I'm all said and done haha

Look at the 2005 Ford Crown Victoria P71 Police Inteceptor. That would be a fun to drive car. Just look for a black one. They are reliable and safe. Plus people slow down because they think there's a cop coming up behind them.

Mazda 6
Honda Accord
Nissan Altima

The Mustangs and Nissan 350 Z are reliable cars when compared to most other similar vehicles.