Is $9,995 a good price for a 2011 Ford Ranger?

2.3L Automatic, 2 wheel drive. Regular cab.

Depends on how good condition and how many miles. But yes i think that sounds like a pretty cheap price for a 2011

That would depend on the overall condition and mileage on the Ranger.

Here, you can look up it's value yourself.

http://www.edmunds.com/appraisal/