Which car should I choose?

I'm in the market for a new car. I was recently in a car accident and my car was "totaled" by my car insurance company. Total sham in my opinion, but I'm not willing to fight for the car since I was not "upside down" on the car loan. Insurance will pay the loan off, and I'll get about $600 back.

So far I have been narrowing my search based on price (under $8000), as well as whether or not I like the style. However, I'm not sure what cars have good/best reputations just based on what I've picked out so far… Can anyone help me with this?

1. 2012 Ford Fiesta 90k miles
2. 2007 VW Jetta 95k miles
3. 2007 Scion tC 110k miles
4. 2007 Pontiac G6 75k miles

2012 Ford Fiesta. It gives economy car shoppers reason to celebrate with its fun-to-drive personality, nicely trimmed cabin, tight build quality and unexpected features. This little Ford looks stylish and even a bit racy, with an urban-runabout element that had been missing from Ford's US lineup. In following, the Fiesta drives just as dashing as it looks, with impressive steering and handling and a nimble, maneuverable feel that's better than most softened, numbed appliances its size. Beyond its slick European good looks, impressive 40-mpg fuel economy, and fun-to-drive factor, the 2012 Ford Fiesta sub-compact is loaded with features uncommon in this class, including a wide variety of wild interior and exterior color choices, a watered-down version of Ford's popular SYNC audio and communications system, and more interior room that one would expect. Which car should I choose - 1

Pay cash or do not buy.