Which cars are the best for me based on what I'm looking for?

I'm getting my permit next week, if I pass the test that is, and I know its a little bit away but I'm already looking for cars. I know I sound spoiled, which maybe I'm, but my brother needs to take the car our parents bought for us to use to college because he's an actor and will need to drive to auditions. I'm very busy and would need a car of my own since both my parents use there's during the day. I love cars that are convertible, and I love the older trucks/jeeps. I live in a smallish town, and not a city. I would like it to have a decent gas millage as well. So far I love Ford Bronco's, but they are "impractical" as my mom calls them and don't have the best millage. I also would live to get a used one, hopefully around 5000-5500$. Does anyone have any ideas? I would mostly use it around town however I might need to drive it long distances every once in a while.

No older truck or jeep is good on gas. Don't get a bronco unless you have time and money. Horrible on gas and break down a lot. But I would recommend a jeep. I picked up my 93 for $4500. They are fun and will never get stuck in the mud (if you're a decent driver) and the 4.0's will last a lifetime. Those motors are tough. They do get annoying for long drives with a soft top so I recommend a hard top for that. Overall I think it's your best bet. Nothing beats taking the doors and top off and just cruising around town.

Toyota Corolla
Honda Civic
Toyota Camry
Honda Accord